---
title: "Almacantar v de Valk: What the Cladding Ruling Means"
url: https://manage.management/blog/almacantar-v-de-valk-what-the-cladding-ruling-means-for-blocks
description: "Almacantar v de Valk: unsafe cladding costs cannot be charged to qualifying leaseholders, whatever the age or risk. What it means for blocks."
author: "Franklin Baeza"
published: 2026-11-22T06:33:20.000Z
updated: 2026-11-22T07:36:24Z
categories: ["Maintenance & Safety","UK Legislation"]
publisher: Manage.Management
language: en-GB
---

# Almacantar v de Valk: What the Cladding Ruling Means

Almacantar v de Valk: unsafe cladding costs cannot be charged to qualifying leaseholders, whatever the age or risk. What it means for blocks.

Qualifying leaseholders cannot be charged for removing or replacing unsafe cladding, however old the building and whatever the danger. That is the effect of [Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd v de Valk [2026] EWCA Civ 1466](https://caselaw.nationalarchives.gov.uk/ewca/civ/2026/1466), handed down by the Court of Appeal on 17 November 2026. The court held that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 is not limited to "relevant defects" from the 30 years before the Act. It also held that "unsafe" is not limited to fire risk.

The case concerned Centre Point House in central London. Thirteen qualifying leaseholders there will not pay towards façade works costing more than £12 million. This guide explains the ruling and what it means for RTM and RMC directors and leaseholders. It is written by Manage.Management, the UK block management platform for RTM and RMC directors, leaseholders and managing agents.

> This article is general information about leasehold blocks in England. It is not legal advice. Whether particular works count as "cladding remediation" is a question of fact for the tribunal, so take advice on your own building before you issue or challenge a demand.

## Key takeaways

- No service charge is payable under a qualifying lease for "cladding remediation", meaning the removal or replacement of any part of a cladding system that forms the outer wall of an external wall system and is unsafe.
- The protection is not tied to the "relevant defect" definition, so the 28 June 1992 to 28 June 2022 window does not apply. A 1960s façade was covered.
- "Unsafe" means "involving danger". A façade at risk of falling apart counts, even with no fire risk.
- Whether something is "cladding" is a question of fact for the First-tier Tribunal. Appeal courts will rarely interfere.
- The court left open whether a building's whole external wall, such as modern curtain walling, can be a cladding system.

## What did the Court of Appeal decide in Almacantar v de Valk?

The court dismissed the freeholders' appeal on all five grounds and upheld the First-tier Tribunal and the Upper Tribunal. Lord Justices Newey, Miles and Fancourt heard the appeal on 15 and 16 October 2026, and the decision was unanimous.

Centre Point House has 36 duplex flats above shops and restaurants. Its 1960s timber-framed façade had let water in for decades. The judgment records that the timber had rotted in many places, frame joints had failed, and a window panel had detached and fallen onto the podium (paragraph 72). The experts agreed the only realistic fix was a new steel curtain wall system fixed to the concrete frame, at more than £12 million including VAT and fees (paragraph 4).

The tribunal found that the works fell within the landlord's repairing covenant, so a service charge was payable in principle. However, under paragraph 8 only tenants without qualifying leases would pay. The Court of Appeal agreed.

## What does paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 say?

Paragraph 8 is one sentence of protection and one definition. The text, quoted at paragraph 21 of the judgment and on [legislation.gov.uk](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/30/schedule/8), reads:

> (1) No service charge is payable under a qualifying lease in respect of cladding remediation.

> (2) In this paragraph "cladding remediation" means the removal or replacement of any part of a cladding system that (a) forms the outer wall of an external wall system, and (b) is unsafe.

The landlords argued for four limits on that wording. The court rejected each one. The table summarises the five grounds of appeal, using the paragraph numbers in the judgment.

| Ground | Landlords' argument | Court's answer |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Paragraph 8 only covers relevant defects | Rejected. Paragraphs 2 to 7 and 9 mention relevant defects; paragraph 8 does not (paras 41 to 54) |
| 2 | Centre Point House has no "cladding" | Rejected. This is a question of fact, and the tribunal was entitled to find a cladding system (paras 80 to 83) |
| 3 | The works were not removal or replacement of a cladding system | Rejected. Much of the system was being removed and replaced (paras 86 to 89) |
| 4 | No cladding system formed the outer wall of an external wall system | Rejected on the facts. Whether a whole external wall can be a cladding system was left open (paras 110 to 113) |
| 5 | "Unsafe" means combustible or a fire spread risk | Rejected. It is an ordinary word meaning "involving danger" (paras 55 to 60) |

## Why does the 30-year cut-off not apply?

Because paragraph 8 never mentions relevant defects. Under [section 120 of the Building Safety Act 2022](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/30/section/120), a relevant defect must arise from works completed in the 30 years before 28 June 2022. The landlords said paragraph 8 should be read the same way.

The court disagreed: "Like the FTT and the UT, we do not consider that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 is limited to 'relevant defects'" (paragraph 54). Most of the other Schedule 8 protections, such as the £10,000 and £15,000 caps for non-cladding defects, still depend on a relevant defect. Paragraph 8 stands apart from them. Our guide to [the Remediation of Unsafe Cladding Bill](https://manage.management/blog/remediation-of-unsafe-cladding-bill-what-it-means-for-leaseholders-and-resident-directors) covers how the wider scheme works.

## Does "unsafe" cladding have to be a fire risk?

No. The court said "'unsafe' is an ordinary English word which, read naturally, simply signifies 'involving danger' and is not restricted to fire risks" (paragraph 58). It added that "it is not only through fire that cladding can inflict harm" (paragraph 59).

So a cladding system that could shed panels, glass or fixings onto people below can be unsafe, as at Centre Point House. Directors should not assume that a façade with a clean fire risk appraisal of external walls (FRAEW) is outside paragraph 8.

## Which leases and buildings does the protection cover?

Only qualifying leases in relevant buildings. Both are defined in the Act, and several types of block fall outside.

1. **Relevant building:** under [section 117](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/30/section/117), a self-contained building in England with at least two dwellings that is at least 11 metres high or has at least five storeys.
2. **Excluded buildings:** blocks where leaseholders have collectively enfranchised or used their right of first refusal or compulsory acquisition, blocks whose freehold is "leaseholder owned" under the regulations, and commonhold.
3. **Qualifying lease:** under [section 119](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2022/30/section/119), a long lease of a single dwelling, with a service charge, granted before 14 February 2022.
4. **Ownership test on 14 February 2022:** the flat was the tenant's only or principal home, or the tenant owned no more than two other UK dwellings.

Tenants who do not meet these conditions, such as larger investors, can still be charged. At Centre Point House, the tenants without qualifying leases remained liable.

## What does the ruling mean for RTM and RMC directors?

If your block is a relevant building, you cannot demand cladding remediation costs from qualifying leaseholders. You also cannot use the [reserve fund](https://manage.management/blog/reserve-funds-sinking-funds-how-much-a-block-should-hold-and-who-decides) to pay for that work. The judgment notes that paragraph 10(2) stops those costs from being treated as service charge costs or met from a reserve fund, and requires any sums already charged to be adjusted (paragraph 24).

This creates a real funding question for resident-led companies. An RTM company or RMC has no money of its own beyond what leaseholders pay. The judgment does not deal with that position, and the court noted that "cladding remediation" will often also be a relevant defect, which opens up developer liability, the government's remediation schemes and remediation contribution orders. Our guide to [remediation contribution orders](https://manage.management/blog/remediation-contribution-orders-what-the-urban-splash-ruling-means-for-leaseholders) explains that route.

Practical steps for directors:

1. **Check whether your block is a relevant building**, using the height, storey and dwelling count tests.
2. **Collect leaseholder deeds of certificate** to identify qualifying leases.
3. **Ask your surveyor whether planned façade work is "cladding remediation"**, including repair-led work that is not about fire.
4. **Pause demands for any cladding element** until you have advice, and keep it out of reserve fund spending.
5. **Record decisions in board minutes**, as part of your [Building Safety Act duties as directors](https://manage.management/blog/building-safety-act-accountable-persons-what-rmc-and-rtm-directors-are-responsible-for).

Manage.Management's [building safety tools](https://manage.management/features/building-safety) keep EWS1 forms, fire risk assessments and other safety records in one place. Remedial actions flagged in a report become tracked issues, so façade problems are not spotted and then forgotten.

## Frequently asked questions

### What is Almacantar v de Valk about?

Almacantar Centre Point Nominee No.1 Ltd v de Valk [2026] EWCA Civ 1466 is a Court of Appeal decision of 17 November 2026. It held that qualifying leaseholders at Centre Point House in London cannot be charged for replacing the building's unsafe 1960s façade, at a cost of more than £12 million. The court ruled that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 to the Building Safety Act 2022 is not limited to relevant defects or to fire risk.

### Does the cladding protection apply to buildings older than 30 years?

Yes. The Court of Appeal held that paragraph 8 of Schedule 8 is not limited to relevant defects, so the 30-year window before 28 June 2022 does not apply. A qualifying leaseholder in a relevant building cannot be charged for removing or replacing an unsafe cladding system, however old it is. Other Schedule 8 protections, such as the caps on non-cladding costs, still depend on a relevant defect.

### Does unsafe cladding have to be a fire risk?

No. The court held that "unsafe" is an ordinary English word meaning "involving danger" and is not restricted to fire risks. At Centre Point House, the danger was rotten timber framing and panels that could fall from the façade. A cladding system that is structurally dangerous can therefore fall within paragraph 8, even if a fire risk appraisal of the external walls raises no concerns.

### Can an RMC use the reserve fund for cladding remediation?

Not for costs that paragraph 8 makes unrecoverable from qualifying leaseholders. Paragraph 10(2) of Schedule 8 stops those costs from being treated as service charge costs or met from a reserve fund, and any sums already charged must be adjusted. Directors should take advice before spending reserve funds on façade work in a relevant building, and look at developer liability and government remediation schemes instead.

### Is a share of freehold block covered by paragraph 8?

Often not. Section 117 of the Building Safety Act 2022 excludes buildings where leaseholders have collectively enfranchised, used their right of first refusal or compulsory acquisition, or where the freehold is leaseholder owned under the regulations. Those blocks are not relevant buildings, so the Schedule 8 protections, including paragraph 8, do not apply. Check how your freehold was acquired before relying on the ruling.

## Almacantar v de Valk: the short answer

The Court of Appeal has confirmed that qualifying leaseholders in relevant buildings cannot be charged for removing or replacing unsafe cladding, whatever its age and whether or not the danger is fire. The 30-year relevant defect window does not limit paragraph 8, and the costs cannot come from the reserve fund. Directors should check their building and leases now, take advice on any façade work, and look to developers and remediation schemes for funding.

Last reviewed: 22 November 2026 by Franklin Baeza, Manage.Management. This article is general information for England, not legal advice. Check the current position with a qualified adviser before acting.

---

Source: [Almacantar v de Valk: What the Cladding Ruling Means](https://manage.management/blog/almacantar-v-de-valk-what-the-cladding-ruling-means-for-blocks) on the Manage.Management blog.
