---
title: "Service Charge Collection Fees: Card vs Direct Debit (2026)"
url: https://manage.management/blog/service-charge-collection-fees-card-direct-debit-bank-transfer-compared
description: "Service charge collection fees compared: card, Direct Debit, Pay by Bank and bank transfer on Stripe, GoCardless and Mollie, checked 20 Nov 2026."
author: "Franklin Baeza"
published: 2026-11-20T06:33:51.000Z
updated: 2026-11-20T07:37:03Z
categories: ["Software & Tools","Service Charges"]
publisher: Manage.Management
language: en-GB
---

# Service Charge Collection Fees: Card vs Direct Debit (2026)

Service charge collection fees compared: card, Direct Debit, Pay by Bank and bank transfer on Stripe, GoCardless and Mollie, checked 20 Nov 2026.

Collecting a £375 quarterly service charge costs a self-managed block anywhere from nothing to about £5.83 per payment for a standard UK card, depending on how the leaseholder pays. A bank transfer usually costs nothing to receive. Bacs Direct Debit through Stripe, GoCardless or Mollie costs £3.58 to £3.95 on a £375 payment. A standard UK card through Stripe costs £5.83, based on each provider's own published UK prices, checked on 20 November 2026. Across a 12-flat block paying quarterly, that is the difference between £0 and about £280 a year.

This guide compares the published fees for card, Direct Debit, Pay by Bank and bank transfer, and explains which method suits which block. It is written by Manage.Management, the UK block management platform for RTM and RMC directors, leaseholders and managing agents. We sell a collection service ourselves, so we state our own price plainly and took every other figure from the provider's own pricing page today.

> This article is general information for blocks in England, not legal or financial advice. Provider prices change often and may differ for your business, so check the current tariff before you sign up.

## Key takeaways

- Bank transfer is the cheapest way to receive a service charge, but you have to match every payment by hand and chase anyone who forgets.
- Bacs Direct Debit costs 0.9% to 1% plus up to 20p per payment, and the caps of £4 to £5.60 make large annual payments cheaper than they first look.
- Card payments are the most expensive, from 1.2% + 20p for UK consumer cards on Mollie to 2.8% + 20p for premium cards on Stripe.
- Pay by Bank is a cheap middle option: Mollie charges 0.45% + 20p.
- Manage.Management's Self-managed plan charges 3% of service charge collected, with no monthly fee, and covers the software as well as collection.

## Which payment methods can a self-managed block offer?

Most blocks offer three or four: bank transfer, Bacs Direct Debit, card and Pay by Bank. The cheapest choice for the block is not always the one leaseholders find easiest, so most blocks offer more than one.

- **Bank transfer (Faster Payments or Bacs credit):** the leaseholder sends money to the block's account using the account number and a reference. It is usually free to receive, but your bank's business tariff may charge per credit.
- **Bacs Direct Debit:** the leaseholder signs a mandate once, and the block collects each instalment automatically. Payments take a few working days and are protected by the Direct Debit Guarantee.
- **Card:** debit or credit card, often through a payment link or portal. Card payments are instant but carry the highest fees.
- **Pay by Bank (open banking):** the leaseholder approves a payment in their banking app, and the money arrives in seconds.

Whichever method you use, the money belongs to the service charge fund. Under [section 42 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1987/31/section/42), service charge contributions are held on trust to pay the relevant costs. Keep them separate from the company's own money and record every receipt against the right flat.

## How much do card, Direct Debit and Pay by Bank cost?

On published UK prices, Direct Debit costs about 1% per payment, cards cost 1.2% to 3.25% plus 20p, and Pay by Bank costs 0.45% plus 20p on Mollie.

Prices checked 20 November 2026, from each provider's own pricing page: [Stripe](https://stripe.com/gb/pricing), [GoCardless](https://gocardless.com/pricing/), [Mollie](https://www.mollie.com/gb/pricing) and [Manage.Management pricing](https://manage.management/pricing).

| Provider or tool | Card | Bacs Direct Debit | Pay by Bank | Monthly fee | Who it suits |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Stripe | Standard UK cards 1.5% + 20p; premium UK cards 2.8% + 20p | 1%, minimum 20p, capped at £4 | No fee stated on the pricing page | None stated | Blocks with a volunteer comfortable setting up payment links and reconciling payouts |
| GoCardless | Not listed on the pricing page | Standard 1% + 20p, capped at £4; +0.3% on payments over £2,000 | Not stated on the pricing page | None for most users | Blocks that want everyone on Direct Debit |
| Mollie | UK consumer cards 1.2% + 20p; UK commercial and European cards 2.9% + 20p | 0.9% + 20p | 0.45% + 20p | £0 on pay as you go | Blocks wanting card, Direct Debit and Pay by Bank from one provider |
| Bank transfer | Not applicable | Not applicable | Not applicable | Your bank's business tariff | Small blocks with a treasurer happy to match payments by hand |
| Manage.Management Self-managed | Included | Included | Included | £0; 3% of service charge collected | RTM and RMC blocks of 4+ flats wanting collection, budgets and arrears reminders in one place |

Two notes on the comparison. GoCardless and Mollie also offer higher-tier or custom plans, so these are their standard published rates. Block management tools such as LevyBoard and Marklet publish software prices, but their pricing pages do not state payment processing fees, so we have not listed them as collection providers. Our guide to [self-managed block software prices](https://manage.management/blog/self-managed-block-software-published-uk-prices-compared-2026) compares their software prices.

## What would a 12-flat block pay in a year?

For a 12-flat block where each flat pays £1,500 a year in four quarterly instalments of £375, provider fees range from £0 to about £280 a year, depending on the method. That is 48 payments and £18,000 collected.

| Method | Fee per £375 payment | Fees for 48 payments a year |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Bank transfer | Usually £0 | Usually £0 |
| Mollie Pay by Bank (0.45% + 20p) | £1.89 | £90.60 |
| Mollie Bacs Direct Debit (0.9% + 20p) | £3.58 | £171.60 |
| Stripe Bacs Direct Debit (1%, £4 cap) | £3.75 | £180.00 |
| GoCardless Standard (1% + 20p, £4 cap) | £3.95 | £189.60 |
| Mollie UK consumer card (1.2% + 20p) | £4.70 | £225.60 |
| Stripe standard UK card (1.5% + 20p) | £5.83 | £279.60 |

These are payment fees only. A block using a payment provider directly still needs a way to issue demands, reconcile payments to each flat and chase arrears. Manage.Management's Self-managed plan would cost £540 a year for this block (3% of £18,000) and covers collection, budgets, demands, ledgers, voting and building safety tracking, with no monthly fee. For a wider view of software costs, see our guide to [how much block management software costs in the UK](https://manage.management/blog/how-much-does-block-management-software-cost-in-the-uk).

If flats pay the full £1,500 once a year instead, the Direct Debit caps matter. Stripe and GoCardless would each charge £4 per payment, or £48 a year for the block, while a standard UK card on Stripe would cost £22.70 per payment.

## Can a block pass card fees on to leaseholders?

Usually not as a surcharge at the point of payment. [Regulation 6A of the Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/uksi/2012/3110/regulation/6A) bans charging a payer a fee for using a consumer card, and the ban has applied since January 2018.

Collection costs paid out of the service charge must still be reasonably incurred under [section 19 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985](https://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/1985/70/section/19), and the lease must allow them to be recovered. Most blocks treat payment fees as a normal running cost in the budget. Take advice before adding any separate fee for a particular payment method.

## How should you choose a collection method?

Start with what will get every leaseholder paying on time, then keep the cost down. Late payments cost a block far more than a 1% fee.

1. **Offer Direct Debit as the default.** Automatic collection reduces arrears, and our guide to [service charge arrears](https://manage.management/blog/service-charge-arrears-what-happens-and-how-to-prevent-them) explains why that matters.
2. **Keep bank transfer available.** Some leaseholders, including landlords and companies, prefer to pay by transfer. Give each flat a unique reference so you can match payments.
3. **Add card or Pay by Bank for one-off payments.** These suit major works contributions and catch-up payments, where speed matters more than the fee.
4. **Check how payouts and reconciliation work.** Ask how quickly money reaches the block's account, and whether each payment is matched to a flat automatically.
5. **Budget the fees.** Put a line for collection costs in the service charge budget, so they are visible to every leaseholder.

## How Manage.Management helps

Manage.Management's [service charge tools](https://manage.management/features/service-charges) let leaseholders pay by Apple Pay, Google Pay, Pay by Bank, Direct Debit or card, or by BACS transfer with no fee. Every payment is reconciled to the right flat, and polite automatic reminders go to anyone in arrears. Our pricing page states that 100% of the service charge principal settles to the building account. To see how demands and ledgers work in practice, read [how Manage.Management handles service charge billing and tracking](https://manage.management/blog/how-manage-management-handles-service-charge-billing-and-tracking).

## Frequently asked questions

### What is the cheapest way to collect service charges?

Bank transfer is usually the cheapest, because most business accounts receive Faster Payments free of charge. The cost is time: someone must match each payment to a flat and chase anyone who has not paid. Among paid methods, Mollie's Pay by Bank was the cheapest published option on 20 November 2026, at 0.45% + 20p per payment, or about £1.89 on a £375 instalment.

### How much does Direct Debit cost for service charges?

On published prices checked on 20 November 2026, Bacs Direct Debit cost 0.9% + 20p on Mollie, 1% (minimum 20p, capped at £4) on Stripe and 1% + 20p (capped at £4) on GoCardless's Standard plan. On a £375 quarterly payment, that is about £3.58 to £3.95. Caps make large annual payments cheaper as a percentage, though GoCardless adds 0.3% above £2,000.

### Can an RMC charge leaseholders extra for paying by card?

Generally not as a surcharge. Regulation 6A of the Consumer Rights (Payment Surcharges) Regulations 2012 bans fees for paying with a consumer card. Collection costs that the block pays can usually be included in the service charge budget, if the lease allows them and they are reasonably incurred under section 19 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1985. Take advice before adding a separate fee.

### Do service charge payments have to go into a separate account?

Service charge contributions are held on trust under section 42 of the Landlord and Tenant Act 1987, to pay the relevant costs and then for the contributing leaseholders. The section does not name a specific type of account, but keeping the money separate from the company's own funds is good practice. It also makes the year-end service charge accounts much easier to prepare.

### How much does Manage.Management charge to collect service charges?

The Self-managed plan costs 3% of service charge collected through the platform, with no monthly software fee, for RTM and RMC blocks of four or more flats. It includes card, Pay by Bank and Direct Debit collection, BACS transfer instructions, budgets, demands, flat ledgers and arrears reminders. For a 12-flat block collecting £18,000 a year, the fee would be £540. Managing agents can ask about the Managed plan.

## Service charge collection fees: the short answer

Bank transfer is usually free but takes the most admin. Bacs Direct Debit costs about 1% per payment, capped at £4 on Stripe and GoCardless, and is the best default for reducing arrears. Cards cost the most, from 1.2% + 20p upwards, and Pay by Bank sits in between at 0.45% + 20p on Mollie. Compare fees alongside the software you need to issue demands and reconcile payments, and check each provider's current price before you choose.

Last reviewed: 20 November 2026 by Franklin Baeza, Manage.Management. This article is general information for England, not legal advice. Check the current position with a qualified adviser before acting.

---

Source: [Service Charge Collection Fees: Card vs Direct Debit (2026)](https://manage.management/blog/service-charge-collection-fees-card-direct-debit-bank-transfer-compared) on the Manage.Management blog.
